Why Polarized Thinking Is Keeping You Stuck

6/13/25

If you’ve ever skipped a workout because you missed one day, or thrown out a whole day of healthy eating because of one donut—you’ve experienced polarized thinking.

Also known as all-or-nothing thinking, this mental habit convinces you that anything less than perfect isn’t worth doing at all. And it’s one of the biggest mindset traps keeping high-achieving women from making real, sustainable progress.

In this post, we’re unpacking what polarized thinking actually is, why it shows up, and how to break the cycle for good.

What Is Polarized Thinking (And Why It’s So Common)

Polarized thinking is a form of cognitive distortion—aka a mental shortcut your brain uses to make sense of the world. It shows up as ‘I’m either all in or all out.’ There’s no middle ground.

Perfectionists are especially prone to this kind of thinking because it creates a false sense of control and safety. It feels easier to believe you're either on track or off, instead of living in the messy middle where progress isn’t always obvious.

Signs You’re Stuck in All-or-Nothing Thinking

This kind of thinking doesn’t always feel black-and-white when you’re the one in it. Here’s how to tell if you might be stuck in the loop:

• You use words like always, never, perfect, or failure to describe your efforts.
• Small wins feel like they don’t count unless they’re big.
• Setbacks feel catastrophic instead of normal.
• You give up easily when something doesn’t go perfectly.
• You feel like you're constantly starting over, especially on Mondays.

This type of thinking can take over every area of your life, but is especially prevalent when it comes to your own health.

Want to listen instead? Find the full episode of The Hidden Perfectionist here:

How It Sabotages Your Health Goals

All-or-nothing thinking creates burnout by demanding perfection. It turns small detours—like one missed workout or one unplanned meal—into full-on spirals that undo your progress. This cycle can lead to emotional eating, binge-restrict patterns, and a deep sense of failure.

This way of thinking is tightly connected to the diet mindset - how we view food and measure progress. Learning to shift that mindset is where progress begins.

Most importantly, polarized thinking disconnects you from consistency, which is the true driver of lasting results.

It’s not about being perfect. It’s about learning how to respond when things aren’t.

How You Can Break the Cycle (And What This Looks Like in Real Life)

It’s not about flipping a switch - it’s about practicing small shifts in the moment to combat polarized thinking. Here’s how that can start to look day to day:

• Catch the thought in the moment: Notice when your brain says “I ruined everything.” Pause and ask, is that really true?
• Reframe your language: “I missed one workout” becomes “That’s normal. I’m still showing up.”
• Set flexible goals: Instead of 5 workouts a week or bust, aim for 3–5. Flexibility builds consistency.
• Celebrate the gray: Small, imperfect choices that lean toward your goal still count.
• Get support if needed: A coach or therapist can help you rewire these patterns.

Here’s what that actually looks like:

Imagine you're trying to read a book. You start out strong but can’t finish the whole thing in one sitting—so you give up and don't touch it again for months. When you finally pick it up, you forgot what you've read and have to start over.

Now picture you're reading a few pages a day. Some days you read a chapter, others you reads nothing—but you keep coming back. Eventually, you finish the book.

That’s the difference between perfectionism and consistency. Real progress comes from returning to the thing, not powering through it in one flawless burst.

Polarized thinking tells you that small steps don’t count. But they do.

They’re the very thing that adds up to big change.

You don’t need more motivation or discipline—you need a new lens.

So whether you’re trying to eat better, move more, or finally start that side hustle—stop waiting for the perfect time or perfect week. Start now and keep going. Consistency isn’t about doing everything—it’s about not giving up.

Want more like this in your inbox? Sign up for my newsletter here. 👇